
"Those are z's." No love for Barry Larkin: Phil Rizzuto's counterpart isn't winning the popularity vote like "Scooter" once did.
Anytime a baseball gets through the middle of the infield, nobody feels more responsible than the shortstop. And when it’s a ball he attempts to make a play on, only to see the hitter reach base safely, it’s like missing the 7:55 AM elevator for an 8:00 o’clock interview.
Forget highlight reels exist for just the next few paragraphs, because most of the clips from out of the shortstop position encourage a slack-jawed reaction based from false pretenses: as the development of the “magical” play most likely gained its momentum thanks in large part to the athlete positioning himself five to ten feet in the wrong direction in the first place.
Cubs shortstop Starlin Castro, like that rotten third-grader who was the first to tell you there was no such thing as Santa Claus, tried his darndest to make this “out of postion” theory common knowledge when he went as far as turning his entire back to the actual battery as the catcher began framing a live pitch…on national TV nonetheless! Eat your heart out, Twitter!

Nobody's perfect. Let's consider the future of National League shortstops: Starlin Castro (pictured), Jose Reyes ('11 "batting champ"), Hanly Ramirez (aka "Hanly Hustle"). At least Colorado's Troy Tulowitzki has juice.
This is not how I remember Barry Larkin: the champion, MVP Cincinnati Red class-act shortstop who was recently elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame. Growing up as a student of the game, I respected Larkin as one of the few pro athletes that made playing his position look easy. He always seemed to be a step or two away from the ball before handling the putout with liquid grace.
Current Yankee great Derek Jeter, widely regarded as a shortstop with limited range (and an imminent outfielder), had to slug and win his way to HOF status while staying out of the tabloids in order to win us over.
For argument’s sake, lets keep Jeter’s regular season stats but pretend he never won a World Series. We would simply see him as a prolific offensive shortstop with all the intangibles, and maybe an above-average defender (28th all-time fielding %). He would be the Craig Biggio of his position.
If you feel that Jeter and Larkin don’t even belong in the same sentence or museum, consider jotting down a list of the greatest shortstops of all time excluding the longtime Red. Here’s what I managed to come up with on my own:
1. Jeter (Should break Tom Seaver’s 1st ballot vote record of 97%)
1A. Cal Ripken (HOF)
The Rest:
Ozzie Smith (HOF)
Jimmy Rollins
Rizzuto
Alan Trammel
Omar Vizquel
Tony Fernandez
Edgar Renteria
After Googling, I added Honus Wagner (who some HOF voters consider the greatest SS ever) and threw in Ernie Banks and Robin Yount (though he played just as many games in the outfield). Then there’s a few more really old timers I could throw in there, but you’ve probably never heard of them. It’s a brief, strange looking list isn’t it? Are you really going to get that upset if I now throw Larkin, a guy who sucked it up and shared astroturf with the Bengals, into the mix?

The Reds' "Nasty Boys" bullpen got most of the credit, but Larkin was the face of the franchise during the 90's and beyond.
With the exception of Renteria, what do all the great shortstops of recent memory have in common? They all have top-tier career fielding percentages. We so often associate Ozzie Smith’s legacy as the greatest fielding shortstop ever, yet his fielding percentage is just a few shades higher than that of Larkin: .978 and .975, respectively. They both played 19 seasons in the Big Leagues as full time shortstops.
Some of the greatest accomplishments in modern day sport include: playing through an entire NFL season without ever having to stare into a small flashlight, earning veteran status in the NBA before buying a fifth car, skating about an NHL season without drinking a single Canadian lager and breaking into the Big Leagues as an infielder. Staying at the top is even more difficult. Now consider the essential position of shortstop, the defensive x-factor, in a sport where defense occupies the field. Larkin led the defense playing behind only one ace pitcher, Jose Rijo, for nearly two decades.




















